Pan-seared Chilean seabass with capers and olives in a dry vermouth sauce over sauteed broccoli rabe and risotto. While those bread-crumbed, super plump oysters were a tad greasy perhaps from vinaigrette dressed greens (and we would have hoped for a better tartar sauce), this kind of sandwich is a noteworthy lunch item for a seaside restaurant to offer. Coral Bay - View the menu for Coral Bay as well as maps, restaurant reviews for Coral Bay and other restaurants in Staten Island, NY and South Beach - Tottenville. Wheelchair access Great deal that includes a full meal from appetizer to dessert from…, From Business: From focusing on quality, clean ingredients to serving our food to you in a warm and welcoming environment, Panera Bread is committed to being an ally to our…. We hope you enjoy your experience at Coral Bay restaurants in Staten Island, and please leave us your review below with YP.com! Neighborhood feel, world-class quality; great place to pick up a drink and run, or if time allows, hang-out for a good vibe. Hurricane Sandy turned Puglia by the Sea, a popular Staten Island restaurant on the Raritan Bay, into a war zone as waves crashed through its windows and took down its walls one year ago. Atmosphere From there, you can expect to choose from some of the best menu items like: For a closer look at the menu items along with their prices, check out the Staten Island Coral Bay menu. Of course, winter is typically a quiet time for the restaurant. YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. ... Anderson's Annex Tavern on Staten Island was completely wiped out, ... Coral Bay Cafe remains closed. All rights reserved (About Us). In fact, on recent visits, we enjoyed some rather nice meals at Coral Bay Cafe.A cup of Manhattan clam chowder was rich with clams, vegetables and appropriate oregano seasoning. Select state Home | Go to Staten Island | ... Coral Bay Cafe-CLOSED | 722 Rockaway Street Staten Island 10307 | 718-356-3531. One of the borough's precious few seaside dining options has made delightful improvements in the past year. (especially the specials if you get in early enough!!! Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Diners Club, Seating Pasta: $13.95-23.95 A large bowl of al dente fusilli with clams, garlic, fresh parsley and butter was extremely flavorful. Staffers are gentle and meek when dealing with kitchen disappointments such as drag time between courses. Pamela Silvestri | silvestri@siadvance.com. Appetizers: $6.95 and up Looking for Coral Bay prices? While we stuck with seafood on most visits (when in Rome, etc. 722 Rockaway St. Desserts are not house made but there is a fair selection including a Torta della Nonna, a chilled slice of pie made with ricotta, eggs and pignoli nuts. Contact AWE restaurant critic Pamela Silvestri at silvestri@siadvance.com. Even more recently, almost one year to the date, Coral Bay Cafe didn't receive the most flattering food review in the AWE section. Surprisingly Coral Bay Cafe is one of the borough's few beach-side restaurants. Fried oysters are also available as an entree item without the bread. Fried oysters came on fresh, glossy hero bread with julienne of mixed greens and diced tomato. It is an attractive, casual eatery nestled at the end of Rockaway Street, a quiet residential block in Tottenville. Seeded mustard flavored a pan-fried, hand-formed crabcake disc. Yelp notes the restaurant has permanently closed, though a tipster informs Eater that the owners hope to reopen elsewhere in the city. Tottenville; Are you in the mood for some restaurant food? All other marks contained herein are the property of their respective owners. 718-356-35312 stars, Food Or you may have called it Jorgneson's at one time. Coral Bay has an average price range between $4.00 and $30.00 per person. Recommended even on weeknights. Oysters Rockefeller had six Blue Points baked with bits of sauteed spinach, diced ham and a sauce that can be likened to a carbonara. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. From Business: Specializing in single origin pour-overs, espresso, and espresso based drinks, protein smoothies, pastries fresh from Brooklyn daily, and healthy snack options…, A warm space, with a nice vibe and a buzz. We'll also recommend waiting a few weeks after this review before trying the restaurant for the first time. Depending on the restaurant food, a variety of factors such as geographic location, specialties, whether or not it is a chain can influence the type of menu items available.